Music Marketing Mayhem
I have a deep antipathy for all things gee-whiz when it comes to marketing; thoughtless, “this oughta be cool” web tools particularly.
With this in mind, imagine my delight when I opened up Springwise today and found this latest bit of absolutely mind-numbing, “what the hell’s for breakfast” marketing ignorance: Sonifics: Soundtracks for Your Digital Life.
What Sonfics offers is a catalog of indy music that you can incorporate into any web site or blog via a flash player. Its free, its easy; its the perfect internet date.
Now my criticism re Sonfics is not about the music or indy artists trying to find their indy niche in the music world…on the contrary, I wish ‘em luck.
Nope, its about the overreaching, ill-informed and down right stupefying suggestion that music, in and of itself, makes for a great marketing idea in conjunction with an eBay listing, which Sonifics does, even going so far as to link to a dummy listing. A listing, I might add that is a poor example of a poor example. Also, there’s a little problem(s) with their recommending using their service within eBay.
So, what’s the problem?
- Oh, where to begin? Well, for starters, music in and of itself is not a motivator unless it is congruent with the product/message being sold.
- Next, it is intrusive to the sales process if it is not, once again, deeply congruent to the whatever it is being sold. Recognizable music that is carefully targeted to the message and product and to the intended demographic is an art when done correctly. An unknown song, an unknown voice entails the mind asking:”who’s that, what am I listening to?” and naturally,”how do I turn it off?” None of which are conducive to the message or to the intended result. Even if the customer has the option to play/not play the music…what is the reason for disrupting the marketing message by presenting the question?
- For those that remember, eBay listings were once awash in flashing applets and insipid sound tracks. They have now, for the most part, disappeared for the simple reason that they were counterproductive to sales. And those sellers that employed them are either now gone or on to other things, equally counterproductive. Its eBay Darwinism.
- Next, Sonifics revenue model is that once someone hears a tune they like, they can click-through on the flash player and purchase it. Simple enough except that when used in an eBay listing this would constitute a redirect of traffic for an off-site transaction. Additionally, they run ads within the stream itself; something I imagine Meg might find irritating. In short, you’d be better off posting your seller ID and password on a Bulgarian Warez site.
- But wait, there’s more! In a prime example of corporate disconnect, Sonific’s terms state:
you may not place SongSpots™ or the code for SongSpots™ on any page, email, programs, servers, websites or other locations on the Internet unless the destination of the SongSpots™ are registered with Sonific in accordance with Sonific’s on-site registration process and unless you control the placement and removal of the SongSpots™ on that destination (the “Destination”) at all times;
As you well know, on eBay you do not control anything as your auction can be DC’d for any reason at anytime.
- It gets better. Again, quoting from Sonific (”Destination” meaning where the audio player is used):
- The Destination cannot be a clearly commercial site used primarily for the sale of products or services;
- The SongSpots™ cannot be placed in such a fashion at the Destination as to be a tie-in to promote another product at the Destination such as for the purposes of a commercial for a product or service;
Yep, eBay isn’t “clearly commercial” and certainly isn’t “used primarily for the sale of products or services”. Its a venue, after all.
So, by my reading of this, you not only risk alienating your customers by employing a thoroughly pointless marketing gizmo but further risk inviting the wrath of one or both Sonifics and eBay.
Not a bad day’s mayhem for the simple insertion of a line of code.
Video and audio can be very effective in an auction or on any e-commerce site…but only if used as a natural, motivating compliment to the message and to the message’s intended result.
Its hard work selling; don’t make it any harder by deploying a tool that cuts both ways.

tag this




Still thinking that your own e-com site will deliver you the profitability you once enjoyed at auction…think again. Brian Smith reports in his ComparisonEngine blog on the
Well, its about time. I’ve *finally* finished the migration of the old site over to this WordPress platform…and I couldn’t be more delighted!..(Your delight, of course, will be the final word).

